Hi Hendred sorry to say I had the same issue a few years ago and yes I should have maybe put my findings on the forum as well and saved you some time !
I fitted a Gel (yellow type) battery and thought I had a weird charging problem until my battery on the digital voltmeter died and I used my good old Avo8. I thought I had an issue with the charge warning light circuit and the Lucas light control relay can but of course no!
Guess what I use all of the time now on my bikes
Old technology always seems to work I guess.